Online Trombone Journal -
Archives  | Classifieds  | JFB  |  Wednesday, June 19, 2019


Explore the Library
Articles by David Vining.
Other Review Articles.
Melody in A Major: A Review
David Vining

Dawes CoverDawes, Charles Gates. Melody in A Major. Arranged and Edited for trombone and piano by John Marcellus. Briar Music Press : [United States]; distributed exclusively by Ensemble Publications : Ithaca, New York, 1998.

This wistful melody was originally written for violin and found its way into the repertoire of none other than Fritz Kreisler. Of Dawes’ work, Kreisler commented “…it has taken my fancy because of its tunefulness and its strong musical value.” Brigadier General Dawes (1865-1951) spent time as a member of the Republican Executive Committee during McKinley’s presidential campaign and was awarded the Nobel Peace Prize in 1925. He served as vice president under Calvin Coolidge and spent time as ambassador to London during Herbert Hoover’s administration.

The tune is a simple ABA form in slow 6/8 time with an eighth note pulse throughout and is 41 measures long. There are several high c-sharps (including the last note) and a number of grace notes to challenge the performer’s range and interpretation. In spite of these difficulties, this melody lies quite comfortably on the trombone and Doc Marcellus has transcribed the violin part with skill. There is an optional cadenza, written by the performer, and the piece is available in arrangements for band and chamber orchestra by rental.

This is a beautiful lyrical melody which would fit nicely into a recital program. Larry Zalkind’s recent release “Encores” includes an exquisite rendition of this piece.

David Vining, assistant professor of trombone at the University of Cincinnati College-Conservatory of Music, offers recitals and clinics to brass players and musicians of all ages. Vining has appeared as a soloist and clinician nationwide and as a guest artist at many conferences.

Articles by David Vining Other Review Articles